Saturday, November 12, 2016

quick note for clarity in today's reading

The first reading at Mass today is from the third letter of John. It includes a reference to strangers that can cause confusion. So a quick note.

“Beloved,’ writes John, “you are faithful in all you do for the brothers, especially for strangers; they have testified to your love before the church. Please help them in a way worthy of God to continue their journey.” (3 John 1:5-6)

It’s fair and proper to read the passage trying to figure out what John thought about strangers. However, this specific passage is not about the proper attitude toward strangers in general; it’s about a pretty specific group – about traveling missionaries. Help them, he says.

People who want to use Scripture to justify protecting Christian refugees in Syria while rejecting Muslim refugees can use (abuse) this passage. John says, help these particular people, because they are ours. That implies that there are other strangers whom we won’t help because they aren’t ours. The passage can be used (abused) to justify building a wall, at least in your heart, between good refugees and bad refugees.


To justify walling out Mexicans (all rapists) and Muslims (all terrorists), you can use this passage. Grab it, if you are an abusive cherry-picker! But people who recall what Jesus said about Samaritans and robbers might want to embrace this passage – and also look at other texts which demand that we expand our definition of “neighbor”!