Afterword by a froward spider

[return to contents]

I am a bridge-builder. I don’t do it well, but I do it. That’s my job, my calling, my vocation – as I see it.

Let me try to explain the job as I see it. I’d like to use a vignette, or maybe just the image behind a story. I am not sure I can communicate this successfully: it may just sound nutty. And I’m ambivalent about saying this out loud: this silly image lives in the depths of my heart, where I am pretty vulnerable. But I’ll just tell it.

It’s not a story, really; it’s just a feeling.

The Church is divided. That has bothered me since college. I remember vividly a reporter for the Harvard Crimson coming around doing interviews for a story he was doing about the issues that were on the minds of freshmen. This was spring 1969: the civil rights movement was in turmoil after the assassinations of Martin Luther King and Bobby Kennedy, and we were in Vietnam, and my brother had been dead for a year. But still, what I said was that what troubled me most was the division in the Catholic Church. A specific example: the students at the Harvard Catholic student center were mostly left-wingers, and the students at the Opus Dei house just off campus were right-wingers – and they despised each other. We needed unity, with diversity.

It bothered me then, and it bothers me still.

Today, still, there is a deep division between the “left” and the “right” – between people who are concerned about social justice including social issues like immigration and refugees on the left, and people who are concerned about personal morality including abortion and marriage on the right. The leadership of the Church is not divided over these issues, but American Catholic laity are. I have done different things about that at different times. But in 2012, it seemed to me that the Lord spoke to me about this division. Not in words in my ear, but nonetheless pretty clearly, so that it would be a lie to deny that I think he spoke, and it would have been disobedient to ignore it. He hit me with a 2X4, because I am very slow to listen; and then he gave me a job. He told me to protect immigrants, and to talk to his people on the right who are treating immigrants with disrespect. (He did not say “right” or “left” – those are my words, my abbreviations for the two sides.) He sent me, so I have tried to respond.

That’s crazy! That guy just said that God talked to me. Catholics don’t do that stuff. What I mean is, I had an urgent idea, which I suspected was from God. I could have been wrong; who am I to discern? But the idea erupted with urgency, so insistent that I would have judged myself disobedient if I had ignored it. I try to listen, try to discern, try to obey.

Since May 2012, I have been going back and forth between the two sides. I am completely certain – completely certain – that this particular divide in the Church is temporary. Soon – who knows the date? soon! – the divide won’t exist. There will still be a left and a right, people emphasizing different things, but there will not be a gulf between them. The bridge will be so wide and the gulf so narrow and shallow that people will go back and forth between the two sides unaware that there was once a serious divide there. It will be like driving down a road and going over a culvert: if you don’t look for it, you won’t see it. That’s coming, for sure, soon. Maybe before this Pope dies. But actually, the time it will happen is absolutely none of my business. I’m supposed to build a bridge.

There will be a highway over a culvert one day, and no one will even notice that they are crossing from one side to the other. But right now there’s a rope bridge over a canyon. (Actually, there are many bridges; but one is mine, and it’s fragile.)

Sometimes, people on one side or the other tear the bridge apart. That’s okay. Well, it’s not okay; they shouldn’t do that; what I mean is, I am okay with my job, which is to re-build that bridge. Sometimes people build bridges, and sometimes they rip them up. I build, and we win.

Sometimes, it’s not even a rope bridge; it’s more like a spider web. I am a spider in the kingdom of God, fastening a strand here, and getting blown across to there, then hustling back and forth to strengthen the nearly invisible line.

Sometimes when I’m trying to strengthen one end of the bridge, people on the other side kick my work apart. That’s a nuisance, but it’s not really a big deal. I wish they wouldn’t, but more for their sakes than for mine. I can and do rebuild. But when a person damages a piece of someone else’s work, they damage themselves.

Sometimes when the spider web gets ripped up at one end or the other while I’m on it, I fall. Truly, this is not a problem at all; these moments are among the best times in the business, because I get to see who else is building across the chasm. I don’t always see them when I’m spinning, but they catch me when I fall, and I get to see them.

One of the other bridge-builders is the Pope. He goes back and forth between the two sides, and people don’t know what to make of him. And – God have mercy on me and protect me from pride – I DO see what he’s doing, because I’m doing it too. He’s a lot better at it. He’s a trip! He’s fun to watch!

Of course the main bridge-builder is Jesus himself. He wants us to take responsibility for building, but he’s in there too. He’s a slender guy, but tougher than hell. He is nailed to the left side and nailed to the right side, which sort of measures the width of the divide: we can’t ever be more than 5-6 feet apart if we are faithful to him. We are nailed to each other! So sometimes when my web gets kicked apart, and I can’t get back to either side, and I just fall, just fall, just a spider in the wind – I land on him.

If I’m not on the left or the right, nor building on a bridge between, I’m not doing my job. But that’s okay, sometimes. My life is more than my work (and my work is more than my job). So I can hang out for a while, sitting on the Lord. Forget the bridge! Just do some little stuff, to make The Bridge-Builder smile. Maybe I can put a few sticky strings between a couple of thorns, to keep flies from messing in the Lord’s blood. Or maybe I can scare the flies away, keeping them out of his eyes. Little stuff, like making an immigrant or a child laugh. Then I get blown back to the left or right, and start work again.

Old friends ask, “Which side are you on?” I understand their question. But I am a bridge-builder, and I belong on both sides, and in between. And I think, my old friends and my dear friends and my dear old friends, that you belong in the chasm too.


John Cavanaugh-O’Keefe, bridge-builder wannabe and occasional spider


[go to next page, "Author's bio"]

[return to contents]